WHY FOURTH ROUND INTERVIEWS ARE A DISASTER

WHY FOURTH ROUND INTERVIEWS ARE A DISASTER
We had a company interview an experienced Sales Business Development Manager. First interview virtual with HR for screening. Second interview with Hiring Manager and "meet some of the team". Third interview with executive. After a week, company representatives determined to seek a fourth interview for the purpose of "let's take one last look". Then they disqualified the candidate because they "just weren't sure she could fit". Nonsense.
I've been running a recruiting operation for 25 years in Detroit. My reaction to the fourth interview was to either ask the company OR the candidate to "throw in the towel" and start over. Both decided to proceed.
Why would I suggest shutting the process down?
There are some universal fundamentals that we watch for:
First of all, three interviews is absolutely appropriate for people generally in positions making over $100,000. These are typically skilled and experienced professionals.
Second, the initial formal interview with a company representative is the official screening for each party to get indicators of whether there could be a match. We don't throw this out because this screening is checking and balancing the outside recruiting company screening efforts. (Was something mismatched or miscommunicated? This is hammered out in the first formal interview.)
Third, we generally view the first face-to-face interview (the 2nd interview) with HR and the Hiring Manager firmly planting the candidate as a legitimate contender to get the job offer or not.
Fourth, a third and FINAL interview is VERY COMMON and typically involves a 0-30,000 foot view by a company executive to solidify the validity of the candidate.
Five, a "meet the team" interview can happen generally in the second or third interview. This is excellent because it allows the candidate to transparently get an overview of the role based on discussions with peers at the same level.
Of course there are exceptions, however, after 25 years, I can decisively commit that BOTH PARTIES have secured their opinion of each other by the end of interview #3. ALWAYS! This is a constant.
As a Recruiter, we are very specific at getting the response from the candidate and also the Hiring Manager. Noone wants time and energy wasted and their feelings about each other SHOULD NEVER BE A SECRET.
If flags are raised after a third interview by either party, this match-up is most likely a disaster which will leave both sides irritated, agitated, and frustrated.
Both sides need to understand that demanding a fourth interview is MOST LIKELY a cave-in and cop-out by the decision makers.
Recent Posts










